The Fanonite

It appears some of Chavez’s defiance is rubbing off on Lula. For the first time since he singled out US citizens for strict visa controls in reponse to the harassment of Brazilian citizens at American airports, Lula is showing signs of a spine.

Brazil’s President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva, has flatly rejected President Bush’s proposals for parallel global negotiations to combat climate change, insisting that countries come to agreement at the United Nations, and not under US leadership…

“The Brazilian position is clear cut,” Mr Lula said. “I cannot accept the idea that we have to build another group to discuss the same issues that were discussed in Kyoto and not fulfilled.

“If you have a multilateral forum [the UN] that makes a democratic decision … then we should work to abide by those rules [rather than] simply to say that I do not agree with Kyoto and that I will develop another institution,” said Mr Lula…

The Bush administration has sought to cultivate President Lula as an ally, seeing the former trade unionist as a centre-left alternative in Latin America to the more radical anti-American socialism espoused by Cuba’s Fidel Castro and Venezuela’s Hugo Chavez…

However, on overall climate change policy, President Lula was dismissive of the Bush approach, calling it “voluntarism”, meaning a reliance on “coalitions of the willing” rather than establish global institutions and the pursuit of voluntary goals rather than binding commitments. “We cannot let voluntarism override multilateralism,” he said…

But Mr Lula, Brazil’s president since 2003, rebuked Mr Bush for seemingly sidestepping the UN and not taking its global responsibilities seriously. “I am open-minded about talking to President Bush … I will never refuse to discuss any idea, but we should respect the decisions made in the multilateral forums. It is the only thing we have all agreed on in a democratic way,” he said. “If the US is the country that most contributes with greenhouse gases, in the world, it should assume more responsibility to reduce emissions.”

The German hosts of this week’s G8 summit at Heiligendamm have also flatly rejected the idea of creating a separate process to deal with climate change. Chancellor Angela Merkel called it “non-negotiable”.

A Yelp in the Corner

Meanwhile in the periphery, a muted yelp was heard.

Tony Blair has been a lonely voice on the world stage, hailing the Bush plan as an “important step forward”.

The Bio-fuel Debate

[Lula's] promotion of bio-fuels has brought criticism from Mr Chavez, the continent’s leading oil producer and Castro, who has argued that growing bio-fuels is equivalent to taking food crops from the mouths of the poor and putting it in the petrol tanks of the wealthy.

Mr Lula picked his words on his fellow presidents carefully. “Its normal that those countries that have oil feel a bit strange about this idea of bio-fuels,” he said, but he suggested it was time for the Latin American left to move beyond its instinctive anti-Americanism. “A long time ago I learned not to put the blame for backwardness in Brazil on the US,” he said. “We have to blame ourselves. Our backwardness is caused by an elite which for a century didn’t think about the majority and subordinated itself to foreign interests.” …

The only more important issue in the world than trade, President Lula said, is climate change, and both are nearing a potential turning point.

“In the Doha round, I want to solve the issues of today and tomorrow,” the Brazilian leader said. “On the climate issue I have to solve the problem of planet earth, the only one we know of on which we can survive … So for God’s sake, let’s take care of planet earth.”